They came in a box – all shapes and sizes of paper and card, most typewritten but one or two brave souls relying on their hand-writing. The judging for the Katikati Haiku Contest is done blind – that is each haiku entered is numbered, I see no names.
I sat down, armed with a pair of scissors, and began to read (the scissors were to cut stand-out poems from a sheet of entries).
I sorted them, sorted them again and then re-read the whole lot for a third time.
I made piles – definite, definite maybes, maybes and, well you get the picture. The piles got shuffled. The piles got shuffled again.
The coffee table, couch and floor were decorated with strips of paper. The strips of paper got moved from one site to another. Well, several of the strips of paper … some of them stayed right where they were for the entire judging process.
Lorin Ford’s winning haiku was in the top four from the start – it’s a complex, profound and mysterious poem.
a last year’s lambskin where mushrooms gather dusk
It’s funny how sometimes there is more than one poem on the same unexpected subject in the same contest. I gave this haiku by Scott Mason a Commended:
I was equally enchanted by the Second-place haiku by Beverley George:
train journey …
the young student next to me
reduces stars to graphs
and by this Highly Commended haiku by Gary Hotham:
floating in calm air
too much light
for the engineer’s math
Third was Simon Hanson (an interesting statistic – all the top three haiku, three of the four Highly Commendeds and two of the six Commendeds were by Australians):
the hare waits
for eye contact
Catherine Bullock of Waihi won the Best Local Haiku award with this great poem:
evening calm –
the width of the estuary
I also want to mention this Highly Commended haiku by Beverley George – while judging the entries I went out one morning to find the snail bait around the parsley had claimed five (five!) snails overnight. I could really envisage those “stretched necks” during the dark hours:
the stretched necks
To read the full list of winners, and my judge’s report, go here.
Unfortunately, we had one disqualification due to haiku being entered that had previously been published. It saves red faces all round if poets keep good records and a track of what’s gone where, when and what happened to those poems (ie, while they may not have been prize winners, were they included in a contest anthology?).